Signal President Warns Against Treating AI Chatbots as Friends

AI Chatbots as Friends">

Signal President Meredith Whittaker is sounding the alarm about the privacy implications of AI chatbots like ChatGPT and Claude. When asked about these chatbots, Whittaker said, "These are not your friends. These are not conscious beings. These are not sentient interlocutors."

Whittaker made these comments in a Bloomberg interview about policy, privacy, and Signal. She does use AI tools occasionally, but only to format documents. She avoids asking them questions, insisting, "I don't ask them questions. I'm very serious about my thinking and writing, and I don't want the process of working through an idea […] to be foreclosed or eclipsed by the response of a system that's averaging what's already out there."

Whittaker also weighed in on Microsoft AI CEO Mustafa Suleyman's prediction that users could let Microsoft Copilot handle all their Christmas shopping this year. Whittaker argued that this scenario, where Copilot would have access to sensitive information, would be a disaster. "What you've just described is a system with very pervasive access across multiple applications and services," she said. "In the context of Signal, it would constitute a kind of a backdoor." Specifically, Whittaker pointed out that such a system would need "access to my credit card, my browser, my Signal, the ability to message my siblings on my behalf, my home address [and] my calendar."

The implications of Whittaker's statements are clear: as AI chatbots become more prevalent, users must be cautious about how they interact with these systems and what information they share. This is particularly important for businesses and developers building AI-powered applications, as they must prioritize user privacy and security to avoid potential backlash and regulatory scrutiny. As AI technology continues to advance, it remains to be seen how regulators and industry leaders will address these concerns and ensure that users are protected. For now, Whittaker's warning serves as a timely reminder to approach AI chatbots with a critical eye and a healthy dose of skepticism.